Sizing up a disagreement: what it is about, and whether to raise it
Write what happened as a camera would record it, name what kind of disagreement it is, decide to raise it, let it go or wait, and check that it is a disagreement and not something else.
- Start here: the essentials
- 1. What happened, and the story about it
- 2. What kind of disagreement it is
- 3. How you tend to handle conflict
- 4. Raise it, let it go, or wait
- 5. Is it a disagreement, or something else?
- 6. See it
- 7. Practice
- 8. Your disagreement
- 9. Check your work
- 10. Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
This chapter asks for one sentence, one label and one decision. Everything marked Go deeper is optional on a first pass.
- Write what happened in one sentence a camera could have recorded. Use a date or a time and leave out what you think it means (What happened, and the story about it).
- Name what it is about: something one of you does not know, what each of you wants, what each of you values, or who gets to decide (What kind of disagreement it is).
- Decide to raise it, to let it go on purpose, or to wait, and write the reason (Raise it, let it go, or wait).
- Check the safety question once. If anything on that list fits, stop here and read When this manual is the wrong tool (Is it a disagreement, or something else?).
Minimum time: about 15 minutes. Done when: your Conversation plan holds the one-sentence observation and a decision with its reason.
1. What happened, and the story about it Understand
Most disagreements arrive as a feeling first and a sentence second. By the time you notice that something is wrong, your mind has usually attached an explanation to it: he does not care, she is doing it on purpose, they think the rules do not apply to them. The explanation feels like part of what happened. It is not. It is a story about what happened, and the other person may tell a different one.
The first skill in this manual is to separate the two. An observation is a description of what happened as your senses reported it, free of judgment, criticism or other analysis, and specific to a time and place. That is the definition Nonviolent Communication's publisher gives in its handout on the four components of Nonviolent Communication. The Yale guide to the DESC script (describe, express, specify, consequences) asks for the same thing in other words: describe the behavior as completely and objectively as possible, just the facts (Yale's DESC guide). We use the plain test of a camera. If a camera could have recorded it, it is an observation. If it needs a mind to interpret it, it is a story.
| A story | An observation a camera could record |
|---|---|
| He doesn't care about our kitchen. | On four of the last five weekday mornings there were dishes in the sink when I came into the kitchen at 6:30. |
| The contractor has abandoned the job. | No one has worked on the bathroom since October 3. The contract's finish date was September 26. |
| She is trying to humiliate me in front of the team. | In Tuesday's meeting she corrected the figure I gave and did not say it to me before. |
| My neighbor lets his dog bark all morning. | The dog barked from about 6:00 to 6:45 on Monday, Tuesday and Thursday. |
Notice what the right-hand column does not contain: a motive, a pattern word such as "never" or "always", a label for the person, or a conclusion about how they feel. It can still contain a number, because a count is something a camera can record. It can contain your own reaction if you state it as yours, but that belongs in a different sentence, and Opening the conversation shows where.
Physical principle Writing the observation slows the story down. Writing "four of five mornings" instead of "never" often shows you that the facts are smaller, or more specific, than the feeling. Sometimes it shows the opposite, and the facts are worse than you let yourself notice. Either result is useful before you speak.
The gap between what happened and the story
The gap is not a flaw to fix. You need stories to act. The problem comes when you treat yours as a fact and open the conversation with it. A conversation that starts with "you obviously don't care" is about the story, and the other person has to defend themselves against a motive instead of answering a question about the dishes. What you want and why returns to this when it asks you to write your guesses about the other person's reasons as guesses.
A quick way to find the story in your sentence is to look for these markers:
- Words about the person's character or intent: lazy, selfish, rude, on purpose, deliberately, doesn't care.
- Words about frequency with no count: "never", "always", "constantly", "every time".
- Verbs of mind reading: thinks, wants, is trying to, is pretending.
- Feelings that are really accusations: "I feel ignored", "I feel attacked". The Nonviolent Communication publisher's appendix on feelings versus evaluations masquerading as feelings lists such words, because they describe what you think someone did to you, not what you feel.
You do not have to remove every marker from your thinking. You only have to remove them from the one sentence you write in your plan. The Draft check and break planner can list the "always" and "never" sentences in a longer draft once you have one.
2. What kind of disagreement it is
Different kinds of disagreement need different first moves. If you treat a missing fact as a clash of wills, you will fight about something a phone call would have settled. If you treat a clash of values as a missing fact, you will keep supplying evidence to someone who is not asking for it. Four kinds cover most everyday cases. They overlap, and a real disagreement often has two. Name the one that seems to drive it.
| Kind | What it sounds like | First move |
|---|---|---|
| Information: one or both of you lacks a fact, or holds a wrong one | "I thought you said Friday." "I didn't know that was a rule." | Find out what each of you actually knows. Read the document, check the message, ask. |
| Interests: you want different things, or the same thing you cannot both have | "I want the car Saturday." "So do I." | Ask why it matters to each of you. See What you want and why. |
| Values: you disagree about what is right or important | "We don't lie to customers." "It's not lying, it's marketing." | Aim to understand and to live alongside, not to win. Some values are not negotiable. |
| Authority: you disagree about who gets to decide | "That's my yard." "It's the association's rule." | Find out who decides, and what the lease, contract, policy or bylaws say. |
Two sources support this sorting. Mississippi State University Extension notes that many conflicts trace to insufficient, incorrect or no information (Understanding and Addressing Conflict). A guide for volunteer boards lists lack of information, differing interests, structural struggles over authority and values as the sources of board conflict, and calls values the most difficult to resolve (Managing Conflict: A Guide for Volunteer Boards). The guide is written for boards, but the four sources apply to a kitchen as well as a boardroom.
A word on interests, because the next chapter depends on it. A position is what you ask for. An interest is why you ask for it. Two people can hold opposite positions and compatible interests, and the work of the conversation is often to move from the first to the second. What you want and why teaches how.
If you cannot tell which kind it is, write "not sure" on your plan and read it again after you have listened. People often learn the kind only when they hear the other side. That is a normal result, not a failure of the exercise.
The kind of disagreement is worth naming because it changes what "winning" would mean. For an information problem, the best outcome is a shared fact. For an interests problem, it is a choice that serves both reasons. For a values problem, it is often mutual respect and a workable boundary. For an authority problem, it is clarity about who decides and a fair way to be heard first. The Beyond Intractability essay on interests, positions, needs and values adds a caution: some needs and deep values are not up for bargaining, and treating them like a price to haggle over can make things worse.
This sorting is a way to decide where to start, not a diagnosis of the other person. Real disagreements mix the four kinds, and the other person may sort theirs differently. Treat your label as a guess to check, and change it when you learn more. If a "values" label is a polite way of saying you do not want to try, say so to yourself.
3. How you tend to handle conflict
People respond to disagreement in recognizable ways. Ralph Kilmann and Kenneth Thomas described five modes along two dimensions: assertiveness, the extent to which you try to satisfy your own concerns, and cooperativeness, the extent to which you try to satisfy the other person's (Kilmann Diagnostics' overview of the Thomas-Kilmann Instrument). Penn State Extension's page on dealing with conflict names the same five strategies.
| Mode | Assertive? | Cooperative? | In one line |
|---|---|---|---|
| Competing | Yes | No | Pursue what you want, at the other's expense if needed. |
| Accommodating | No | Yes | Set your concerns aside to meet theirs. |
| Avoiding | No | No | Sidestep or postpone. |
| Collaborating | Yes | Yes | Work to meet both sets of concerns. |
| Compromising | Moderate | Moderate | Each gives up something to reach a middle. |
Kilmann's overview says each person is capable of using all five modes. That matters, because it means the modes describe habits and choices, not types of people. You might compete with a sibling, accommodate a boss and avoid a neighbor. Use the table to notice what you are doing now and whether you chose it. Do not use it to label the other person. A label such as "he's a competer" turns a behavior into a verdict, which is the habit this chapter is trying to loosen.
The modes also have limits. The five were developed in a Western research setting, and an open textbook on interpersonal communication notes that the model carries a Western bias (Communicating with Purpose, section 6.2). Styles, and how direct it is polite to be, vary across cultures and families. If the other person's way of disagreeing looks strange to you, it may be ordinary where they learned it.
When each mode fits
Harvard's Program on Negotiation summarizes when each mode is the sensible choice (Conflict-Management Styles: Pitfalls and Best Practices). In its account, avoiding fits when someone seems volatile or when you do not expect to deal with them again. Accommodating can fit when someone with authority is unhappy about something that went wrong. Competing can fit once value has been created and must be divided. Compromising can settle a minor issue quickly. The same article warns that compromise is often unsatisfying and temporary because it does not address the root issues, and it suggests spending less time diagnosing each other's style and more time on open collaboration.
Kilmann himself writes that collaborating promises a win-win outcome but works only under the right conditions: you need time, and overwhelming stress rules it out. He adds that a dispute along one dimension, such as a wage of $12 an hour against $16, is a poor fit for collaborating, while a package with many dimensions can reach a win-win (Kilmann's 16 tips for using the TKI). The Program on Negotiation article also reports a finding from John Gottman's work with couples: validating, conflict-avoidant and volatile couples can all be stable, as long as both partners use the same style. The textbook section adds that compromising is a partial win and a partial loss, not a win-win. These sources agree on the main point. No mode is correct everywhere, and the useful question is whether the mode you are using fits this situation.
Both Kilmann Diagnostics and the Myers-Briggs Company sell the assessment. You do not need it for anything in this manual, and we do not link to a paid product as a recommendation.
4. Raise it, let it go, or wait
Once you know what happened and what kind of problem it is, you have three honest choices. You can raise it, you can let it go on purpose, or you can wait for a stated reason. The words "on purpose" and "stated reason" carry the weight. The choice you want to avoid is the fourth one, which is not choosing: letting it sit because starting feels uncomfortable.
Kilmann draws a useful line between two kinds of avoiding. "Good avoiding" is leaving a conflict on purpose, to collect more information, to wait for tempers to calm down, or because the issue turns out not to matter. "Bad avoiding" is when the topic is very important to everyone but you, and you are not comfortable confronting it (Kilmann's 16 tips). The University of Toledo's counseling center describes what bad avoiding feels like from inside: frustration that builds like a pressure cooker and can end in an outburst and guilt (Communication Styles). If you have been quietly counting small offenses for weeks, you are probably in the second category.
| Choice | A good reason | A reason to look at again |
|---|---|---|
| Raise it | It happens often, it affects something you care about, and you expect to deal with this person again. | You want to raise it only to prove you are right. |
| Let it go, on purpose | It did not matter once you wrote it down, or you will not deal with this person again. | You find yourself replaying it every day for a week. |
| Wait | Tempers are high, you need a fact first, or the other person is in a crisis. You can name when you will look at it again. | You cannot say what you are waiting for or until when. |
Two more points help with the choice. First, raise things early. The Gottman Institute advises one issue at a time and starting before frustration builds (Manage Conflict: The Six Skills), and a Lamar University roommate guide gives the same advice for a shared room: do not wait until a problem has grown (Roommate Agreement Instruction Guide). Second, how often you expect to deal with the person matters. The Program on Negotiation article above says avoiding can be sensible when you do not expect to deal with someone again. If your setup says this is a one-time dealing, letting it go may be the right call. If it says the relationship matters, a small problem left alone usually does not stay small.
Write the reason, not just the choice. "Raise it: it happens most weeknights and I expect to keep living here" is a decision. "Raise it" is a mood. When you come back to the plan after a hard day, the reason tells you whether to keep the decision.
Preference If you decide to wait, write down what you are waiting for and the date you will look at it again. Waiting with no end date is avoiding.
5. Is it a disagreement, or something else?
Everything in this manual assumes two people who can disagree safely. A disagreement is about an issue: who washes the dishes, where the tree goes, what the schedule should be. It can be loud and unpleasant and still be a disagreement. Abuse is something different. The National Domestic Violence Hotline defines it as a pattern of behaviors used by one partner to maintain power and control over another, which can include physical violence, threats, emotional abuse or financial control, and which usually appears in more than one form at once (Understand Relationship Abuse).
The Hotline's handout on conflict resolution draws the line between ordinary arguments and abuse. It says there is conflict in every relationship and that disagreeing is not necessarily bad. It also says that if you cannot express yourself without fear of retaliation, you may be experiencing abuse, and that one sign of an abusive relationship is a partner who tries to control or manipulate you (Conflict Resolution handout). Its page on healthy relationships places relationships on a spectrum from healthy to abusive, with unhealthy in between. Unhealthy is not the same as abusive, and a relationship with a lot of fighting is not automatically either.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention describe intimate partner violence as abuse or aggression in a romantic relationship, including physical violence, sexual violence, stalking and psychological aggression, and note that it can range from one episode to chronic and severe episodes (About Intimate Partner Violence). A single act of violence or a threat is enough to stop and look at When this manual is the wrong tool. You do not need a pattern before you take it seriously.
Use these questions as a check, not a test. Any one of them is a reason to stop and read the safety page before you plan a conversation.
- Has this person hurt you, or threatened to?
- Are you afraid of what they will do if you bring this up, or when the conversation ends?
- Do they control where you go, who you see, your money or your phone?
- Do they stop you from leaving a room or a conversation?
- Do they insult or humiliate you, and ignore you when you ask them to stop?
At work the same line exists in different words. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration defines workplace violence as any act or threat of physical violence, harassment, intimidation or other threatening behavior at the work site (OSHA, Workplace Violence). The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission's page on harassment describes unlawful harassment as unwelcome conduct based on a protected characteristic, and says petty slights, annoyances and isolated incidents will not rise to the level of illegality unless extremely serious (EEOC, Harassment). That page carried a notice on 2026-11-07 that it was being reviewed and would be revised, so read the current version before you rely on it. Threats and harassment go to your employer's process, human resources or the EEOC, not to a one-on-one conversation. At work and in groups explains where each one goes.
This chapter helps you decide whether to raise a disagreement. It does not decide whether what is happening to you is abuse, harassment or a crime, and it cannot do that from a short checklist. If you answered yes or not sure to the safety question in setup, or any question above fits, set the conversation steps aside and read When this manual is the wrong tool. In an emergency, call 911. The National Domestic Violence Hotline answers at 800-799-7233, by text (START to 88788) and by chat at thehotline.org. The five modes above describe habits. They do not label a person.
6. See it See it
Maya and Eli (invented for this manual). Maya Torres, 31, a dental hygienist, shares a two-bedroom rented apartment with Eli Brooks, 33, a line cook who works until about 11 p.m. four nights a week. Maya uses she/her and Eli uses he/him. They found each other through a listing 14 months ago and get along.
Known: Most weeknights this month there have been dishes in the sink when Maya makes breakfast at 6:30. She leaves for a 7:15 commute. She has not raised it. Eli's shifts end around 11 p.m. on four nights.
Assumed (by Maya): that Eli leaves the dishes because he is tired after work, and that he would want to know it bothers her. Eli settles both when he answers. Maya also has a separate, unraised matter about Eli's partner staying over midweek. She chooses to keep it out of this conversation, because one issue at a time is easier to hear.
Open: what Eli actually wants about the dishes (Eli settles this, in the listening part of the conversation); whether the lease limits overnight guests (Maya settles this by reading the lease, and At home covers it).
Maya starts with her plan. She writes the story first, to get it out of her head: "He doesn't care about the apartment." Then she crosses out every marker and writes the observation: "Most weeknights this month there have been dishes in the sink when I make breakfast at 6:30." She labels the kind as interests: she wants a clear counter and a calm start before her commute, and she guesses he wants something about his night. She writes the decision: "Raise it. It happens most weeknights, it affects my mornings, and we expect to keep living together." She answers the safety question: no.
The table below puts Teresa Alvarez's case beside Maya's, so you can see the same steps on a very different problem.
| Maya (housemate) | Teresa (hired contractor) | |
|---|---|---|
| Observation | Dishes in the sink most weeknights at 6:30. | On October 17 the bathroom tile is half set. The contract's finish date was September 26. Ray's invoice includes a $640 charge for a tile change. |
| Kind | Interests (and information about Eli's shifts). | Information first: what the contract says about delays and changes. |
| Decision | Raise it. | Raise it, after reading the contract, and keep a Log and documents. |
| Safety | No. | No. |
Teresa Alvarez, 45, an insurance claims adjuster, hired Ray Dunn, 50, owner of Dunn Home Renovation (fictional), for an $18,400 bathroom remodel. Teresa uses she/her and Ray uses he/him. Her story is that Ray has stopped caring about her job. Her observation is smaller and more useful. The decision to raise it is easy, but the first move is to read the contract, because what the contract says about delays and changes decides what she can ask for. Neighbors, landlords and people you hired follows her through it.
Two free reads show the same sorting from other angles. The Community Tool Box section on conflict resolution from the University of Kansas starts with understanding the conflict before anything else, and states plainly that conflict resolution is no substitute for safety planning or formal procedures when there is violence, abuse, harassment, coercion or threats. The Gottman Institute's six skills begin with a gentle start, which depends on knowing what happened before you open your mouth.
7. Practice Practice
Minimum: write one observation and one decision on the Conversation plan. Time: about 20 minutes. Materials: the plan sheet, or paper and a pen.
- Get the story out. Write the sentence you say to yourself about the problem, the angry one. Do not edit it. Set a timer for two minutes.
- Find the markers. Underline each word about character, intent, mind reading, or a frequency with no count.
- Write the observation. One sentence, with a date, a time or a count. Read it aloud and ask whether a camera could have recorded it.
- Name the kind. Choose information, interests, values or authority, or write "not sure". Add one line on why.
- Decide. Choose to raise it, let it go or wait. Write the reason. If you chose to wait, write what you are waiting for and the date you will look again.
- Run the safety check. Read the five questions in Is it a disagreement, or something else?. If any fit, stop and open When this manual is the wrong tool.
Optional exercise for a larger situation. If you have several grievances with the same person, list them all. Sort each into information, interests, values or authority. Pick the one that is easiest to describe with a camera and that matters most. Raise only that one. The rest go on a list you look at again after the first is settled. Time: about 30 minutes.
8. Your disagreement Your disagreement
9. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Could a camera have recorded your observation? Does it contain a date, a time or a count?
- Is it free of "always", "never", a label for the person, and a guess about their motive?
- Does your decision (raise, let go, wait) have a written reason, and if you chose to wait, a date to look again?
- Did you read the safety questions once, and answer them honestly?
Worked example
Maya's sentence passes: it has a time (6:30), a place (the sink) and a rough count ("most weeknights this month"). It could be tighter. She replaces "most weeknights" with "four of the last five weekday mornings" after she checks, because a count is easier to agree with than an impression. Her kind (interests) is a guess she will check by listening. Her decision has a reason.
Common mistakes
- Hiding a story in the observation. "The dishes were left out again" contains "again". Test every adverb.
- Treating the label as a finding. "It's a values issue" can end a conversation before it starts. Write "I think" in front of the kind.
- Choosing to let it go and then keeping score. Letting go on purpose means you stop collecting evidence. If you cannot stop, that is information too.
- Bundling. Dishes and guests and rent are three conversations. Pick one.
What is still unresolved
This chapter cannot tell you what the other person sees, so the kind and your reason stay guesses until you hear them. Listening so they feel heard covers how. It cannot tell you whether you should raise something that sits inside a lease, a contract or an employer's rules. For that, read the document and see Getting a third party. And it cannot judge whether a situation is abusive. Only you, with help from the lines on When this manual is the wrong tool, can decide that.