Getting a third party: mediation, ombuds, and when talking has run out
Match your situation to the kind of help that fits, find one local program, ask what it costs and what is confidential, and check deadlines before waiting.
- Start here: the essentials
- 1. Understand: what mediation is
- Community mediation centers
- Voluntary, required and confidential
- Organizational ombuds
- Agencies, the BBB, HR and small claims
- Deadlines that talking does not pause
- When not to mediate
- More about the programs
- 2. See it
- 3. Practice
- 4. Your disagreement
- 5. Check your work
- 6. Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
Talking sometimes runs out: you have tried, the other person will not move, or nothing has changed. This chapter asks for four things: say what you have tried, pick the kind of help that fits, find one local program, and check deadlines. It does not ask you to decide anything else.
- Write what you have tried and what is still open. Two or three lines, with dates if you have them (see what mediation is).
- Name the kind of help that fits. Open Where to take it next and read the row for your situation (see Agencies, the BBB, HR and small claims).
- Find one local program and ask two questions. Ask what it costs and what is confidential (see Community mediation centers and Voluntary, required and confidential).
- Check for a deadline before you wait. A lease, a contract, a policy or a legal time limit may not pause while you talk (see Deadlines).
Minimum time: about 30 minutes plus one phone call. Done when: the help table's row for your situation is open and you have one program's name and phone number, or a reason none fits.
1. What mediation is Understand
A position is what you ask for, and an interest is why it matters; a third party often helps people get from the first to the second. What you want and why covers the terms. This chapter covers who can help when the two of you cannot do it alone.
Mediation is a conversation between people who disagree, led by a trained neutral person called a mediator. The mediator does not decide who is right and does not impose a solution. That is how four different sources define it: the National Association for Community Mediation (NAFCM), the Virginia court system's mediation page, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission's mediation page and Community Mediation Maryland's Need Mediation? page. Community Mediation Maryland puts it as helping people have a difficult conversation, get clear about what matters to everyone, and make decisions; the participants speak for themselves and make their own decisions. The Virginia page adds that the process helps parties recognize their underlying needs and areas of agreement.
Notice what that definition leaves out. A mediator does not rule on a fact, award money or force anyone to attend. If you want someone to decide, you want a different forum (small claims court, arbitration). A mediator also does not give you legal advice. Convention
Other third parties work differently. A facilitator helps a group run a meeting. An ombuds hears concerns inside an organization (see Organizational ombuds). An arbitrator decides, like a private judge. A counselor or therapist works with you on your own or with a partner. We do not cover arbitration or counseling in detail. At home names counseling as the next step for couples. Where we describe a program below, we describe one place's program, with the date we read it, as an example.
Community mediation centers
For neighbors, housemates, landlords and tenants, family, coworkers and small money disputes, the usual first stop is a community mediation center. NAFCM's FAQ lists typical cases: neighbor disputes such as noise, landlord and tenant, coworkers, breach of contracts, property disputes, HOA matters, animal-related problems and parenting issues. Mediators include staff and trained community volunteers. NAFCM says all community mediation centers offer free or low-cost services on a sliding scale, and tells you to ask your local center for exact costs. Community Mediation Maryland says no one is turned away for inability to pay.
The cost promise comes with limits. Michigan's annual report says its centers provide services without cost to indigent parties and that grants do not cover the full cost of running them, so others may pay a fee. Treat "free" as "often free or low-cost; ask."
Finding one
NAFCM's center finder redirected to a member login when we read it on 2026-11-07, so the public cannot use it without an account. Use one of these routes instead:
- Search for your state's court system "alternative dispute resolution" or "community mediation" page. New York's courts list Community Dispute Resolution Centers (read 2026-11-07), and Michigan's courts run a Community Dispute Resolution Program with centers in all 83 counties.
- Ask the clerk of your local small claims or housing court which dispute resolution center they refer people to. Texas's State Law Library says a professional mediator at a dispute resolution center might be able to help with a small claims dispute.
- Ask your city or county. Many fund a mediation program for neighbor disputes. The program may be tied to code enforcement, a library or a legal aid office.
When you call, ask four things: What does it cost? What happens in a session and how long does it take? What is confidential? Will you contact the other person, or should I? Community Mediation Maryland notes that a referrer should check that at least one participant wants mediation; most programs also contact the other person themselves.
What the programs report
Two program reports give figures, each for its own state and year. They are program statistics, not controlled studies, and the two define their numbers differently.
| Program (read 2026-11-07) | What it says |
|---|---|
| New York, Community Dispute Resolution Centers | The centers help more than 75,000 New Yorkers each year. 70 percent of mediations held result in a mutual agreement; 88 percent of clients surveyed would recommend the centers. Most services are low or no cost. The 70 percent counts mediations that took place, not all requests. |
| Michigan, Community Dispute Resolution Program, 2024 annual report | 16 centers; 15,724 cases managed; 63 percent of cases settled; 72 percent of agreements kept; average mediation 1.3 hours; 30 days to disposition on average. |
Do not read either figure as a chance that your own case will settle. They count different things, they come from programs describing themselves, and your case may differ from the average.
Voluntary, required and confidential
Mediation is usually voluntary. The EEOC says its mediation program is completely voluntary, and the Virginia court page says the process in that state is voluntary and confidential. Two exceptions show that "voluntary" has limits.
- Required: California's court self-help site says that if you have a court date for custody and visitation, the law says you will have to go to mediation before seeing the judge, and some courts use child custody recommending counseling, where the counselor can make a recommendation to the judge (see the court's explanation, read 2026-11-07). Nevada requires alternative dispute resolution before a civil action on a homeowners association matter, and a court may dismiss a case filed first (see the state's brochure, undated, read 2026-11-07). Both are examples from one state.
- Confidential, with exceptions: what is protected depends on the state's law, the court rule or program, and any agreement you sign. A law firm's post on the Uniform Mediation Act, a model law adopted in a minority of states, says that under the act mediation communications are generally not admissible or discoverable, with exceptions for threats or plans of violence or crime, communications used to commit a crime, certain abuse or neglect matters, and limited court findings (see the post, a law firm's, not the model law's drafters). Maryland's mediation association points to a Maryland statute and court rules. Where we do not name your state, we do not know your state's rule.
Ask the mediator before you start: What is confidential here? What would you have to report? Could anything I say be used in court or reported to an agency? Ask the authority
Organizational ombuds
An organizational ombuds is a confidential, neutral, informal and independent person inside an organization (a university, a hospital, a company, a government agency) who helps people think through a concern. These are four principles that the International Ombuds Association (IOA) lists on its page What is an organizational ombuds? An ombuds listens while staying neutral about the facts, helps reframe issues and weigh options, coaches you to deal directly with the other person, refers you to formal channels, and sometimes runs informal mediation.
The same page says what an ombuds does not do: take part in formal investigations, make binding decisions, institute corrective measures, create or maintain records, or receive notice or act as an office of notice for the organization. That last point surprises people. Convention Telling an ombuds about a problem does not put the organization on notice. If you need a formal record or a legal clock to run, you must also use the formal channel. See the IOA's Standards of Practice (the 2022 version is current; the association has invited review of 2026 clarifications).
Not every office called an "ombudsman" follows this model. A state long-term care ombudsman or an HOA ombudsman, for example, has a different role. Ask: Are you confidential? Do you keep records? Can you report what I tell you? At work and in groups shows where an ombuds fits in a workplace.
Agencies, the BBB, HR and small claims
Not every dispute goes to a mediation center. The table lists the main alternatives. The Where to take it next page has the fuller version with costs and what to bring.
| Help | What it does | What it does not do |
|---|---|---|
| State attorney general consumer mediation | Mediates between a consumer and a business, by phone and letter. Maryland's attorney general says it acts as an impartial mediator. Kansas lists home construction and improvement disputes and vehicle repair among the cases it can mediate. | Maryland's office says it cannot force a business to cooperate. It does not give legal advice or act as your lawyer. |
| Better Business Bureau (BBB) | Accepts a complaint about a business that meets its rules. | It is a private, nonprofit group. It does not accept employer and employee disputes, complaints against private individuals not in business, or complaints in litigation, and the issue must be less than 12 months old. |
| State contractor licensing board | In states that license the trade, investigates violations of licensing law and can discipline a licensed or unlicensed contractor. | California's board says its investigation is not to obtain restitution and does not guarantee it; for money back, it points to the courts. |
| HR or employee relations | Takes workplace concerns through the employer's process. | Does not pause legal time limits. |
| Small claims court | Decides money disputes up to a limit set by the state; several state court pages say you sue without a lawyer. | Judges can only award money. It is a formal step, not a conversation. |
A few notes on each, with the sources.
Attorney general consumer mediation. Maryland's Office of the Attorney General says a business receives a copy of your complaint, mediation runs by phone and written correspondence, complaints become public records, and anonymous complaints cannot be mediated (see its business complaints page, read 2026-11-07). If mediation fails, the office mentions free binding arbitration if both parties agree, or small claims. Kansas's attorney general offers a mediation program for people who filed a complaint (phone 1-800-432-2310 on its page, read 2026-11-07). Your state's rules differ; check whether your state's attorney general or consumer protection office offers mediation.
The BBB. The BBB's complaint acceptance guidelines say it strongly encourages you to contact the business first and requires an online account; only one complaint per business per three months is accepted. It is not a government agency and cannot compel a response.
A licensing board. California's Contractors State License Board, one example, takes complaints about violations of the Contractors License Law for up to four years from the act, and asks whether you formally notified the contractor and suggests keeping a copy of your letter (see its complaint page, read 2026-11-07; its listed phone is (800) 321-CSLB (2752)). Other states' boards differ, and some states do not license every trade. Ask your state's contractor licensing board whether it licenses the trade you hired.
Small claims. Small claims is a formal step. The California courts' self-help guide says the court wants you to ask the other side for the money before starting a case, by letter, email or in person, saying how much and why, and the Texas State Law Library recommends trying to resolve problems with the other party on your own. Limits vary by state; see the Go deeper section.
HR and employer processes. At work and in groups covers these in full.
Deadlines that talking does not pause
Talking, even mediation, does not stop a legal clock. The EEOC says a charge generally must be filed within 180 calendar days, or 300 where a state or local agency enforces a similar law, and that these limits generally will not be extended while you try an internal grievance, a union grievance, arbitration or mediation (see time limits for filing a charge). Two universities say the same of their own processes: the University of California, Berkeley and UC San Diego both state that informal attempts do not extend the time limits for filing complaints or grievances.
The same logic applies outside work. A lease may require written notice by a date; a contract may have a warranty period; a licensing board may have a four-year window; the BBB wants issues from the last 12 months; a small claims case has a state limitation period we have not read for your state. Before you wait for a conversation or a mediation date, find the dates. Ask the authority The clerk of a court self-help center, a legal aid office or a lawyer can tell you which dates apply to you.
When not to mediate
Every program named in this chapter is an example from one state, and its fees, rules and confidentiality are as its page stated on 2026-11-07. This manual does not say which forum you should use, whether you have a claim, or whether a deadline has passed. It says what each forum does and how to ask a local center or court self-help office. If the other person has hurt you, threatened you or controls you, or you are afraid of what happens after a joint session, do not set up a joint session. Use When this manual is the wrong tool.
Joint mediation assumes two people who can speak freely. When there is abuse, that assumption fails. The Michigan courts' screening protocol for mediators presumes that cases in which domestic violence is present are not suitable for mediation. The presumption can be overcome only if the abused party wants to mediate and the case indicates mediation will be a safe, effective tool, and mediation should not proceed if the abused party does not wish to participate. The protocol gives reasons: the abuser's desire for power and control, fear that keeps a person from asserting needs, access to the victim, and the risk of retaliation (see the protocol). It is one state's rule, and other states differ.
The National Domestic Violence Hotline does not encourage anyone in an abusive relationship to seek counseling with their partner, and says abuse is not a relationship problem (see its explanation). A county handout in Oregon lists twelve reasons why couples counseling is not recommended when domestic violence is present, including that a focus on the relationship implies both contribute to the abuse and that fear may keep a person from being honest in session. If a court or program asks you to mediate and you are afraid, tell them. California's custody mediators, for example, can arrange separate rooms or different appointment times if you tell them you are worried about safety.
If you are in danger now, call 911. The Hotline answers at 800-799-7233 (text START to 88788, or chat at thehotline.org).
The nine hallmarks of community mediation
NAFCM's nine hallmarks were agreed at a gathering of center leaders in Las Vegas in 1992. Among them: centers are open to trained community volunteers, accessible by self-referral, low-cost (serving people regardless of ability to pay), timely (a forum at the earliest stage of conflict) and an alternative to the judicial system at any stage. They are statements of aspiration; individual centers apply them as best fits local needs.
The Uniform Mediation Act
The Uniform Mediation Act is a model law from the Uniform Law Commission (2001) that a minority of states have adopted. We could not read the Commission's own adoption count (its site renders only with scripts), and the law-firm post we cite counts Connecticut as the thirteenth state to enact it, effective October 1, 2025. If your state has not adopted it, your state's own statutes or court rules govern.
Why abuse is screened out
The Michigan protocol also says its questionnaire is for separate interviews with each party before mediation and is not to be handed to parties to fill in and return. Separate screening is the point: a person cannot honestly answer in front of the person they fear. Other states (Georgia, Maryland, North Dakota and Ohio appeared in our search results) also screen; we have not read their rules.
Small claims limits
A Connecticut legislative research office surveyed all 50 states in January 2023 and reported general limits from $2,500 in Kentucky to $25,000 in Delaware and Tennessee; limits vary within New York and North Carolina, and some states set different limits for specific case types. That survey is more than three years old, so use it for the range only. Three current examples, each read 2026-11-07: California says generally up to $12,500 ($6,250 for a business), a filing fee of $30 to $100, a trial in about one to two months, and no lawyer in court; New York says up to $10,000 in New York City, up to $5,000 in Nassau County and western Suffolk County, and up to $5,000 in City Courts or $3,000 in Town and Village Courts elsewhere; the Texas State Law Library says the limit cannot exceed $20,000. The survey is the Connecticut Office of Legislative Research report.
Mediation for a parent's care
Community Mediation Maryland offers caregiver mediation, free to all, for caregivers or people receiving care who face conflict (its brochure is dated 2021; toll-free 888-826-2262 on that brochure). It is one state's program. Private elder mediators elsewhere may charge fees; we did not find a source to quote.
2. See it See it
Teresa Alvarez and Ray Dunn, continued. Teresa (she/her) and Ray (he/him) agreed in Options and agreements that Teresa pays $410 for the tile change and Ray finishes the bathroom by November 7. Suppose November 7 passes and the tile is still half set.
What is known: the contract is for $18,400; Teresa has paid $11,040; $7,360 is due at completion; the follow-up email recorded the agreement. What is assumed: that the contract says changes must be in writing with a price and says nothing about delays (Teresa read it; she settles that). What is open: whether the delay breaches the contract, which a court self-help center, her state's consumer office or a lawyer settles, and whether any time limit applies to her. She does not know yet.
What Teresa does. She writes down what she has tried: the conversation, the follow-up email with the agreed date of November 7, and the fact that the date has passed. She opens Where to take it next and reads the rows for someone she hired: talking directly, the state attorney general's mediation unit, a licensing board if her state licenses the trade, and small claims. In the fictional case she picks the attorney general's mediation unit, as the case notes say, because she wants a neutral to ask Ray for a date without ending the job. She checks her contract and her state's rules for any time limit that applies, and writes down what she finds and what she cannot tell. She does not withhold the $7,360 on her own; she asks the unit whether withholding payment is something she should do and gets that answer from her state's consumer office or a lawyer. Small claims is named and not chosen; she will ask for the money first if she goes that way. Under these assumptions this is one reasonable path to try. It does not tell us that Ray owes her anything.
- Maryland Attorney General: business complaints: how one state's consumer mediation works, chosen because it says plainly what the office cannot do.
- What is an organizational ombuds?, International Ombuds Association: chosen because it lists what an ombuds does not do.
3. Practice Practice
Minimum: pick the row in Where to take it next that fits your situation, look up one program, and write down its name, phone number, cost and one confidentiality question. Time: about 40 minutes. Materials: a phone or search engine and your Log and documents sheet.
- Write the summary. Write what you have tried, with dates, and what is still open, in under five lines. Add it to your log.
- Pick the row. Read the rows that apply to your setup. For each, ask: does this help decide something, or help us talk?
- Find one program. Use the finding routes in Community mediation centers or search "[your state] attorney general consumer complaint mediation."
- Make the call or send the email. Ask what it costs, what is confidential, whether they will contact the other person, and what to bring. Write down the answers and the date.
- Check the dates. List every deadline you found in your lease, contract, policy or the program's rules, with the date each runs out.
If you are weighing small claims, also read your state court's own page for the current limit and the filing fee, and write a one-paragraph demand letter that says how much and why. The California courts' guide has sample letters. Do not send it until you know whether the court wants you to ask first.
4. Your disagreement Your disagreement
5. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Can you say in under five lines what you have tried and what is still open?
- Did you read what the help you picked does and does not do?
- Do you have one program's name and phone number, and its cost and confidentiality answers?
- Have you listed every deadline you found, with a date?
- If safety is a question, have you read When this manual is the wrong tool before setting up a joint session?
Worked example
Teresa's summary lists three contacts and the November 7 date. She picked the attorney general's mediation unit and has its phone number. The unit's page says it cannot force a business to cooperate, so she knows what to expect. She listed the deadlines she found in the contract and wrote that she does not know her state's small claims time limit. The one gap is that she has not asked what is confidential, which she adds to her call.
Common mistakes
- Assuming mediation or a complaint stops a deadline. It does not.
- Choosing a forum that decides when you want a conversation, or the reverse.
- Treating a state's program page as the rule where you live.
- Telling an ombuds and assuming the organization has been told.
What is still unresolved
This chapter does not tell you which forum to use or whether you have a claim. Your lease, contract, policy and local law decide that, and a court self-help center, legal aid or a lawyer can apply them. For disputes with neighbors, landlords or contractors, Neighbors, landlords and people you hired covers the steps before and after this one; for work and groups, At work and in groups.