Options and agreements: finding choices, a fair standard, and who does what by when
List options before judging any, agree on a fair outside standard, write the choice as who does what by when, and set a date to check how it is going.
Start here Essentials
This chapter asks for four things after you have talked: a list of at least three options, a fair standard to choose by, one written row that says who does what by when, and a date to check. It works for one person and one agreement.
- List at least three options together. Write them down before either of you says what is wrong with any of them (see options before choices).
- Agree on a fair standard. Pick something outside both of you that you will use to choose: a price, a written rule, a schedule you both can keep (see A fair standard).
- Write the choice as who does what by when. One row for each action, with a name and a date (see Writing it down).
- Set a date to check. Pick a day, put it in the agreement, and ask each other then whether it is working (see Following up).
Minimum time: about 30 minutes, once you have both talked. Done when: the Agreement and check-ins sheet has at least one row with who, what and by when, and a check-in date.
1. Options before choices Understand
Once you have talked and listened, the temptation is to jump to the first solution that comes to mind and argue for it. Principled negotiation, the method taught by the Harvard Negotiation Project and summarized by Harvard's Program on Negotiation, treats that as the mistake. Its four elements are to separate the people from the problem, to focus on interests instead of positions, to invent options before committing, and to use objective criteria (see the program's summary). A position is what you ask for, and an interest is why it matters to you; options are the ways of meeting both people's interests, and you cannot see them until the interests are on the table. What you want and why shows how to get there.
Brainstorm, then evaluate, then choose
Gordon Training International teaches a six-step "no-lose" method for parents and partners, and says it applies to anyone. Its middle steps give the pattern: brainstorm without evaluating, then evaluate by asking "Any reason it might not work?", then choose, with both people freely choosing. The Community Tool Box says to generate ideas before evaluating and to make the problem, not the people, the focus. Mississippi State University Extension adds a ground rule for groups: no interruptions and no criticism of others' ideas until all the ideas are on the table. Convention
Put those together into a short procedure:
- State the problem in one shared sentence. Use both people's interests: "We need a clear sink by 8 a.m. and a way for Eli not to wash up at midnight." If you cannot agree on that sentence, you are not ready to brainstorm.
- Call out ideas without judging. One person writes. Silly ideas are allowed. Do not say "that won't work" yet; do not say "that's great" either, because praise is a judgment too.
- Look for the reasons. After the list stops growing, go through it and ask of each option "any reason it might not work?" Cross out options that fail an interest for either person.
- Choose freely. Gordon's method says both people must choose. If one of you gives in to end the conversation, that is likely to show up again as a slipped agreement.
The Gordon page is a sales site for a training company, so we take the structure and leave the claims about results. The pattern also matches the Community Tool Box and extension guidance, which is why we rely on it. Preference
Where the options come from
Options usually hide in the interests. Maya wants a clear sink before 6:30 a.m. Eli, a line cook who finishes after 11 p.m., does not want to wash up at midnight. Those two interests do not conflict, so the options can be wide: wash before bed, soak in a tub, wash when Eli wakes, trade a different household task, buy more plates. A single position ("wash up before bed") would have closed that off. Mississippi State's guide puts the question to ask as: what goals, needs or concerns do you think need to be addressed to resolve this? Ask the authority In your own case, the authority is the other person. Ask them.
A fair standard
Some choices are not matters of taste. How should you split a cost, set a deadline, or decide whose schedule wins? Principled negotiation says to agree in advance on objective criteria: fair, independent standards, such as a published price, a written rule, a contract, or a quote from a third person. The Program on Negotiation's key point is that you agree on which standard applies before you look at what it produces. Otherwise you each pick the standard that favors you.
| The question | A standard to consider |
|---|---|
| How much is a fair price for the extra work? | The supplier's invoice, a quote from a second contractor, a published price list. |
| Who does what at home? | Each person's schedule, time available, and the tasks each finds tolerable. |
| Is the noise too loud? | The quiet hours in a local ordinance or lease (look them up; they differ by place). |
| How should a shared cost be divided? | Equal shares, shares by income, or shares by use: pick one before you look at the numbers. |
| What counts as "done"? | The contract's description, a photo of the finished work, an inspection by a third person. |
A standard has to be outside the two of you, and it has to be something both would accept before knowing the result. If the standard is "whatever I say is reasonable," it is a position. Convention When a standard lets one person decide, expect the other to resist it.
When no option fits
Not every disagreement has a solution that satisfies both people. Four honest outcomes exist when the list does not produce one.
- A compromise. Each gives up something. The Program on Negotiation's guide on conflict styles notes that compromise is often unsatisfying and temporary because it does not address the root issues. It fits a minor issue that you want to settle quickly. Convention
- A split. Kilmann's guidance on collaboration says it fits a many-sided problem with time and a better outcome possible, and that a one-number dispute (the wage example: $12 or $16 an hour) is a poor fit. For a one-number dispute, expect a split.
- One person gives way, on purpose. The same guidance describes accommodating as reasonable when the issue matters more to the other person. The word to notice is on purpose.
- No agreement. Penn State Extension says that in the end, no agreement may be reached. A University of Florida extension sheet says it is perfectly acceptable to agree to disagree on some issues. Say it plainly: "We do not agree on this, and we will each do X." Then do the fallback you already wrote on your Conversation plan (see What you want and why), or take it to Getting a third party.
Win-win is an aim, not a promise. The Program on Negotiation says many situations that look purely win-lose can, with careful questioning and listening, become chances for mutual gain. The word is can. The same page quotes a Harvard Business School professor: sometimes getting 70 percent of the small pie is better than 50 percent of a marginally larger one. Some interests are values or basic needs and are not negotiable. If you reach that, say so; do not pretend to a compromise.
An agreement between two people records what they intend. Whether it is legally binding is a legal question this manual does not answer. A signed agreement reached through the EEOC's formal mediation, for example, is enforceable in court like any other contract, according to the agency's mediation page (a program that starts only after a charge is filed); a note on the fridge is not that. Where money, property or a lease is involved, ask a lawyer, legal aid or a court self-help center before you sign anything new. Getting a third party names who to ask. The agreement also does not settle who was right.
Writing it down
An agreement that lives only in memory gets two versions. Both Gordon's method and the Family Caregiver Alliance's family meeting guide close with writing: "who does what by when" in the first, and a written summary of what each person agreed to in the second. The University of Florida's negotiation exercise adds a step: both people review the agreement aloud. The University of California, Irvine's guide on best practices adds: document it and send it back to the other person. Convention
Use the Agreement and check-ins sheet. It has fields for the date, who is involved, what you agreed in a sentence, how you will know it is working, what you do if it slips, the check-in date, and the date you sent it. A second sheet lists the actions as rows: who, does what, by when, done.
Rules for a row
- Name a person. "We will keep the sink clear" has no owner. "Eli washes or soaks his dishes before bed; Maya rinses hers" has two.
- Use a verb and a thing. "Send the revised schedule" is something either of you could check. "Be more communicative" is not.
- Put a date on it. A date or a clear event ("before the tile setter starts") is the "by when." Without one, no one can tell when it has slipped.
- Write how you will know. One line: "the sink is clear at 8 a.m. on weekdays."
- Write what happens if it slips. The default is a new conversation about the agreement, not about the person. If you add a consequence, make it a real, proportionate next step you will take, and not a threat. "If the tile is not set by November 7, I will contact my state's attorney general's mediation unit" tells the other person what comes next. "Or else I will make your life difficult" does not belong in an agreement.
When you are done, send the written version to the other person, in the same medium you talked in or in writing, and ask them to reply if anything is wrong. Writing it down in Neighbors, landlords and people you hired shows the follow-up email for a hired job. For messages between people who share children, keep them brief and neutral.
Following up and the check-in
A University of California, Irvine guide for resolving disputes suggests choosing a time to check in, notes that it typically requires more than one check-in, and recommends asking "Did action items occur?" Gordon's method ends the same way, with an agreement to check back that the solution works for both. The interval is your call.
When you save a talk date in setup, the agreement sheet fills the check-in date in 14 days later. That is our default, not a rule from any source: two weeks is long enough for a new habit to show and short enough to catch a slipping agreement. Change it. A contractor with a delivery date, or a work schedule, may need a different day.
At the check-in, ask three questions and write the answers in the Check-ins table:
- What held?
- What did not?
- What do we change?
If something slipped, resist the story that it proves something about the person. Talk about the agreement: was it too much, was the date wrong, did something change? That keeps the problem, not the person, as the focus. If it slips again and again, Getting a third party covers the next step. If you agreed something and it did not hold, you can also go back to Making a clear request and make the request smaller.
The no-lose method in six steps
Gordon's page sets the stage first: both people understand and agree to use the method. Then six steps: (1) define the problem, with each person stating needs without blame in I-messages, listening first, and agreeing on the actual problem; (2) brainstorm without evaluating; (3) evaluate; (4) choose; (5) decide who does what by when; (6) agree to check back. Read the full description.
A four-statement exchange
The University of Florida's negotiation exercise has Person A state the current situation, the ideal situation, their feelings, and what they are willing to do. Person B paraphrases, then they swap. Then they ask "Do we have a resolution?" and if so both review the agreement. The module notes that value conflicts and incompatible goals may need more complex tools and perhaps a third party. See the publication.
Integrative and distributive bargaining
Distributive bargaining is a fight over a fixed amount, and integrative bargaining tries to expand what is on the table first. The Program on Negotiation's page contrasts a position ("$12,000 for the car") with an interest ("I need money quickly for a move"). It also warns that giving too much information to a purely distributive counterpart can weaken your position. That caution fits a stranger selling a car better than a housemate.
Facilitator ground rules for a group
The Mississippi State guide, written for extension agents and facilitators, lists ground rules for a group brainstorm: no interruptions and no criticism of others' ideas until all ideas are on the table. It also notes that many conflicts trace to insufficient, incorrect or missing information; ask what each person knows before you brainstorm. See the guide.
2. See it See it
Teresa Alvarez and Ray Dunn. Teresa (she/her), an insurance claims adjuster, hired Ray Dunn (he/him), owner of Dunn Home Renovation (fictional), to remodel her bathroom for $18,400. The contract's finish date was September 26. She has paid $11,040 (60 percent) on the contract's schedule; $7,360 is due at completion. On October 17 the job is three weeks late, tile is half set, and Ray has added a $640 charge for a tile change Teresa agreed to by text without a price.
What is known: the amounts and dates above. What is assumed: that the contract requires changes to be in writing with a price (Teresa read it; she settles this). What is open: why the job is late (Ray settles that; in Listening so they feel heard he says his tile setter left and a second job overran), the right amount for the change, and the new finish date.
Options Teresa and Ray write without judging: (1) Teresa pays the $640 as billed; (2) they split it; (3) Teresa pays only the supplier's price difference for the new tile; (4) Ray drops the charge and Teresa accepts a later finish date; (5) a third person prices the tile. Fair standard: the supplier's invoice. It says the price difference is $410.
The agreement (written in a follow-up email): Teresa pays $410 for the tile change, not $640; Ray finishes by November 7; Ray sends the supplier's invoice by Friday; they check in by phone the following Friday. If it slips: Teresa will contact her state's attorney general's mediation unit; small claims is named and not chosen. Under these assumptions, this keeps the job going and leaves $7,360 unpaid until the work is done. Whether the contract allows the $410, or whether the delay breaches it, is a legal question for the court self-help center or a lawyer, not for the agreement.
- Principled negotiation, Program on Negotiation: the four elements and the sibling anniversary-party example, chosen because it shows interests opening up options.
- Conflict resolution best practices, University of California, Irvine: follow-up and documentation, chosen because it says plainly that one check-in is usually not enough.
3. Practice Practice
Minimum: list three options for a real or past disagreement, name one fair standard, and write one row of the agreement. Time: about 40 minutes. Materials: the Agreement and check-ins sheet and a timer.
- Set a timer for five minutes and list options. Write every option you can think of for an old disagreement. Do not cross out anything. See how long you can keep going after you run out of obvious ones.
- Find the interest behind each option. Next to each, write which interest it meets (yours or theirs). Options that meet neither can go.
- Name a standard. For the choice between two options, name something outside you both that would settle it.
- Write the row. Name a person, a verb, a thing and a date. Read it aloud and ask whether a stranger could tell whether it happened.
- Set the check-in. Pick a date and write what you will ask.
For a recurring disagreement, write the agreement as two rows, one for each person, then add a "what we do if it slips" line and check it a week later. In the Practice sheets, tick the exercise "List options for an old disagreement without judging them."
4. Your disagreement Your disagreement
5. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Did you write at least three options before saying what was wrong with any?
- Did you agree on a standard before you looked at what it produced?
- Does every action row name a person, an action and a date?
- Could a stranger tell, on the check-in date, whether it happened?
- Is the check-in date written, and does the other person know about it?
Worked example
Teresa's agreement lists one person per action and a date for each: Teresa pays $410; Ray finishes by November 7 and sends the invoice by Friday. The standard (the supplier's invoice) was agreed before the amount was known. The check-in is a phone call the next Friday. The agreement leaves one thing out: how Teresa will know the work is "done." She could add "photos of the finished tile and a walk-through." That is a gap the criteria catch.
Common mistakes
- Writing "we will try to" instead of a verb and a date.
- Choosing a standard after seeing which option it favors.
- Treating a compromise as a win-win when neither person's interest is met.
- Skipping the check-in because the first week went well.
What is still unresolved
This chapter does not settle whether your agreement is legally binding, and it does not say what to do if the other person will not talk. Getting a third party covers those. For a household, At home carries a household sheet. If the agreement is about money and a contractor, Neighbors, landlords and people you hired carries the written follow-up.