When it heats up: repair, pausing, and apologizing
Spot criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling, use repair phrases you agreed on in advance, call a pause well, and apologize for your part.
- Start here: the essentials
- 1. Understand: the four patterns that escalate a conversation
- Repair attempts
- Calling a pause in the middle of a conversation
- Apologizing for your part
- When children are around
- When the conversation stops
- 2. See it
- 3. Practice
- 4. Your disagreement
- 5. Check your work
- 6. Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
A conversation that is going well can still tip. This chapter asks for four small things you can do in about twenty minutes before the conversation: choose two phrases that interrupt a spiral, know the two habits to catch in yourself, decide how you would call a pause, and write an apology if you owe one.
- Pick two repair phrases. Choose two short sentences you would be willing to say and to hear, such as "Let me try that again" or "Can we slow down?" (see Repair attempts).
- Catch criticism and defensiveness in yourself. When you notice either, stop and restate it as a complaint about one thing (see the four patterns).
- Know how you would call a pause. If it keeps rising, say that you need a break and name the time you will come back (see Calling a pause).
- Write your apology if you owe one. Say what you did, that you are sorry, and what you will do to fix it (see Apologizing for your part).
Minimum time: about 20 minutes. Done when: two repair phrases, and an apology for your part if you have one, are written on your Conversation plan.
1. The four patterns that escalate a conversation Understand
This chapter assumes two people who can disagree safely. A position is what you ask for, and an interest is why it matters to you; when a conversation heats up, people usually stop talking about interests and defend positions. What you want and why covers how to separate them. Here we deal with what happens to the talk itself.
The Gottman Institute, a couples-research and training organization, describes four patterns that speed up an argument. It calls them the Four Horsemen. Its descriptions come from observing couples, and we use them here for any pair of people, which the Institute does not claim to have tested. Convention Treat them as habits to notice, not as labels for a person.
| Pattern | What it sounds like | What to try instead |
|---|---|---|
| Criticism: an attack on the person rather than a complaint about one event | "You never think about anyone else." "You are so lazy." | A gentle start: say what happened and how it affected you. The Institute suggests asking yourself "What do I feel? What do I need?" before you speak. |
| Contempt: speaking from a position of being better than the other person (sarcasm, mocking, rolling your eyes) | "Oh, sorry, I forgot you are perfect." | Say what you appreciate, even when you are annoyed. The Institute calls this building a culture of appreciation. |
| Defensiveness: usually a reply to criticism that pushes the blame back | "It's not my fault, you do it too." | Accept responsibility for one part, however small. |
| Stonewalling: withdrawing from the conversation, often because a person is flooded | Silence, leaving the room, looking at a phone. | Say that you are flooded, take a break of at least 20 minutes, and come back. |
The Institute's page on recognizing the four patterns separates a complaint from criticism with an example: "I was scared when you were running late and didn't call me" is a complaint, because it names one event and one feeling. Its companion page on the antidotes gives the alternatives in the table: a soft start-up for criticism, appreciation for contempt, taking responsibility for part of the problem for defensiveness, and self-soothing for stonewalling.
Why the patterns feed each other
The patterns tend to run in a chain. A criticism invites a defense. A defense feels like an excuse, so the first person criticizes harder. One of them feels worse and worse, and goes quiet. The quiet reads as indifference, which is a new thing to criticize. You can interrupt the chain at any point, and the easiest point is your own next sentence.
The Community Tool Box from the University of Kansas gives a plain version of the same advice for any dispute: do not answer escalation with escalation, and let people change their position without humiliation. Preference That second point matters more than it looks. If agreeing with the other person costs them face, they will keep arguing a point they have already given up on. Leave them a way to change their mind that does not require them to say you were right.
Catching it in yourself
You cannot reliably catch a pattern in the other person, and naming it out loud ("you are being defensive") usually becomes a criticism of its own. Catch it in yourself. Three signs are worth learning:
- You start a sentence with "you always" or "you never." That is criticism. Restate it as one event: "Last night the dishes were in the sink again."
- You are building a reply while they are still talking. That is the start of defensiveness. Try to find one thing they said that is true, and say that first.
- You have stopped answering, or you are thinking about leaving. That is stonewalling, and it often means you are flooded. Cooling down explains flooding and how to take a break.
Repair attempts
A repair attempt is any statement or action that keeps negativity from spiraling out of control. That is the definition the Gottman Institute uses, and the Institute's writer on the subject stresses that the attempt can be silly, as long as both people know what it means. In one example on its page, a couple threw a yellow football flag to stop an escalating argument. Its page on repair also describes a Repair Checklist with groups of phrases, including ones that say how you feel, ones that say sorry, ones that look for a yes, and ones that stop the action. We do not reproduce the checklist. The categories are enough to build your own list.
Three practical points follow from that page:
- Agree on them before you need them. A repair phrase only works if the other person hears it as a repair. If you have not discussed it, "Can we slow down?" may sound like another complaint. When you can, tell the other person which phrases you would like to use and ask for theirs.
- Choose phrases you would not resent hearing. The Institute notes that "calm down" is not a repair attempt, because it tells a person how to feel. Phrases that describe your own state work better: "I'm getting tense," "I want to understand this."
- Accept an attempt when it comes. A repair attempt fails if the other person ignores it or turns it into a point. A reply as short as "Okay" or "Thank you" lets it work.
Here are starting phrases in our own words, grouped by what they do. The Phrases page has more and lets you filter by setting.
| What it does | Phrases |
|---|---|
| Says how you feel | "I'm getting tense." "I'm worried I'm not explaining this well." |
| Takes back a bad moment | "Let me try that again." "That came out harsher than I meant." |
| Slows things down | "Can we slow down?" "Can we start over?" |
| Looks for a yes | "What part of this can we agree on?" "I can see why you would feel that way." |
| Stops the action | "I need a break. Can we pick this up at seven?" |
The Institute's writing links repair to outcomes: John Gottman's account of the research says that the failure of repair attempts marks an unhappy future for a couple. That claim, and the figures around it, are the Institute's own, and we look at them in the Go deeper section below. For everyday use you do not need the figure. A repair phrase is cheap, it costs a few seconds, and it gives the other person a chance to step back.
Calling a pause in the middle of a conversation
Cooling down covers the break you plan for before a conversation. This section covers the one you call in the middle, when you feel yourself tipping. It has three parts and takes one sentence.
- Name it about yourself. Say "I'm flooded and need a break," not "you are making me angry" or "you are yelling." The first is a fact about you. The second is an accusation, and it will start another round.
- Say when you will come back. Penn State Extension advises that if you need to calm down first, you explain that you understand the issue matters and set a time to return to it. Kilmann, who developed a well-known conflict-style instrument, makes the same point in his tool tips: naming a reason and a time reads as respect, while walking out reads as abandonment.
- Actually go, and actually come back. Take at least 20 minutes, which is the Gottman Institute's guidance, and spend the time on something calming that is not replaying the argument. Come back at the time you named. The break planner works out the clock time and writes the sentence.
Children respond to this difference. In a diary study of 116 families, the tactics that children found distressing included marital withdrawal. Storming out without saying when you will return counts as withdrawal; announcing a break and returning is a different act. Preference We think the announcement is the part that matters, but the study measured diary reports of tactics, not breaks as we describe them.
The person who calls the pause is responsible for restarting. If the other person calls it, let them go. Following them around the house to finish the sentence turns a break into a chase.
If the pause is refused. If the other person will not let you leave, blocks the door, follows you, or you are afraid of what will happen when you return, this is not a pause problem. Read When this manual is the wrong tool.
Apologizing for your part
An apology is a repair that looks backward: it names something you did and tries to fix it. The Community Tool Box recommends apologizing when you caused harm, and Penn State Extension suggests doing it at the outset, for whatever wrongdoing you may have contributed. Apologizing for your part does not mean agreeing the whole disagreement is your fault, and it does not settle the question of who is right.
Researchers at Ohio State University studied what makes an apology work. They broke an apology into six elements:
- an expression of regret ("I'm sorry")
- an explanation of what went wrong
- an acknowledgment of responsibility ("it was my mistake")
- a declaration of repentance (saying you will not do it again)
- an offer of repair ("I will fix it")
- a request for forgiveness
In two experiments with 755 people in total, readers rated an apology as more effective when it had more of these elements. Acknowledging responsibility was rated most important, and an offer of repair was second. Regret, explanation and repentance tied for third. A request for forgiveness was rated least important, and the university's release says it is the one you can leave out if you have to. You can read the Ohio State summary of the study.
The study has limits, and they matter if you want to rely on it. Participants read a written apology in a hiring scenario about a mistake on a tax return. The researchers did not test voice, eye contact or a real relationship. Test it The findings show which parts readers valued in that setting. They do not give a formula that guarantees forgiveness.
Turn the ranking into a short structure:
- Say what you did. Be specific and leave out "if": "I snapped at you and called you lazy," not "I'm sorry if you were hurt."
- Say that you are sorry. One sentence.
- Offer repair. Say what you will do about it: "I'll bring it up when I'm calm, and I'll start with what happened, not with you."
- Stop. Skip "can you forgive me?" and skip the explanation if it sounds like an excuse. Forgiveness is theirs to give, on their own schedule.
Two cautions. First, an apology that carries a "but" ("I'm sorry, but you started it") cancels itself. Say your part, then deal with theirs in a separate conversation. Second, apologize only for what you did. An apology for something you do not think you did, offered to end an argument, tends to come back later as resentment.
When children are around
How people argue is part of what children learn about conflict. Cummings and colleagues studied 116 families with children aged 8 to 16 and asked parents to keep diaries of their disagreements. The conflict tactics children found distressing were threats, personal insults, verbal hostility, defensiveness, nonverbal hostility, withdrawal and physical distress. The tactics that raised children's sense of emotional security were calm discussion, support and affection. The study found associations from diary reports, not proof that one thing caused another. Read the abstract in PubMed.
A Notre Dame release summarizing two three-year studies from the same research group says the pattern held across ages, with effects seen in children as young as one. Insults, defensiveness and refusing to address problems went with insecurity, depression and behavior problems. Parents who worked through a conflict while showing affection and problem-solving made their children feel more secure (see the university release). This is the researchers' own plain-language account of their work, so treat it as a summary, not as a separate study.
Three habits follow if children live with you or are around:
- Keep the repair visible. If an argument ends with a pause and a return, a child who saw the first part can see the second.
- Do not make arguing routine. A University of Florida extension script, an archived copy from 2009 that quotes one psychologist, cautions against turning arguing into a habit or repeating the same argument with no solution.
- Do not use a child as a go-between. If a child has to carry a message, the child is in the conflict. At home covers messages between people who share children.
When the conversation stops
Repair and apology techniques are for conversations between people who can disagree safely. If someone threatens you, will not let you leave, or you are afraid of what will happen afterwards, stop. The National Domestic Violence Hotline's handout on conflict says that if you cannot express yourself without fear of retaliation, you may be experiencing abuse. Use When this manual is the wrong tool. The apology study used a written apology in a hiring scenario; it shows which parts readers valued there, not a formula that guarantees forgiveness. These are our summaries of the sources, not advice that fits your case.
The Hotline's conflict resolution handout draws the line between an ordinary argument and something worse. For an ordinary argument it suggests setting boundaries: if someone curses, calls names or ridicules, tell them to stop, and if they do not, walk away. It says an argument should not devolve into degrading or humiliating comments. If a pattern of control is present, the advice changes, and this manual's methods are the wrong tool. A single threat, or fear of how the other person will react, is enough to stop and read the safety page.
Ordinary conversations also have a stopping point that is not about safety. If you have called a pause twice and the same thing happens when you come back, the conversation is not working in this format. Getting a third party covers other options, including a neutral person in the room.
The Gottman figures, and the critique of them
The Gottman Institute's research page says that across seven longitudinal studies, its methods predicted divorce with an average of over 90 percent accuracy. A 2000 paper by Gottman and Levenson reports that its model predicted divorce with 93 percent accuracy over 14 years (see the paper's record). A page by John Gottman on six predictors says the outcome of a conversation can be predicted 96 percent of the time from its first three minutes, and that the heart of a flooded person can pound at over 100 beats a minute, as high as 165. Those percentages are the originator's claims and carry no study citation on the page. Heyman and Slep, in a 2001 paper on predicting divorce without cross-validation, argue that accuracy figures from a model tested on the same data it was built from drop sharply when the model is tested on new data. In their demonstration, an equation that was right 90 percent of the time on its own sample was accurate in predicting divorce only 29 percent of the time on an independent half. Their data were different from Gottman's, so they show the statistical problem, not that his figures are wrong. The Institute also says that contempt is the single greatest predictor of divorce. Read that as the Institute's claim.
The five to one ratio
The Institute's page on the magic relationship ratio says that, during conflict, stable and happy marriages in its study had five or more positive interactions for each negative one. That is an average Gottman observed in 15-minute conflict conversations among couples, not a target to count in your own conversations, and it was not measured across all of daily life.
The apology research in more detail
Lewicki, Polin and Lount report in the journal Negotiation and Conflict Management Research that apologies with more components were more effective than those with fewer, and that an apology after a competence-based violation (a mistake) was seen as more effective than one after an integrity-based violation (a lapse in honesty). A meta-analysis of 175 studies and 26,006 participants by Fehr, Gelfand and Nag found that apology, empathy and perceived intent were each related to forgiveness: the correlation for apology was .42, for state empathy .51, and for perceived intent -.49 (the more the harm looks intended, the less forgiveness). State anger was -.41. These are correlations, and the studies mix scenarios and recalled events.
Children: more reading
Cummings, in a 2003 Notre Dame profile on parents' hands, calls "not in front of the children" unproductive: children sense tension and benefit from seeing parents resolve conflict well. The same piece says high marital conflict is linked to more aggression in children. The archived University of Florida script adds only that some topics may need to wait depending on the child's age.
2. See it See it
Maya Torres and Eli Brooks (fictional housemates; Maya uses she/her, Eli uses he/him). Maya has raised the dishes for the first time. She opened with "Most weeknights this month there have been dishes in the sink when I make breakfast at 6:30." Eli, tired after a shift, said "It's not like you never leave a mug out." Maya felt her face go hot and said "You never wash up, and you never even notice." Eli stopped talking and picked up his phone.
What is known: Maya used "never" twice and turned a complaint about dishes into a verdict. Eli's first sentence was defensive, and his silence afterward looks like stonewalling. Both are patterns the table describes.
What is assumed: Maya assumes Eli does not care. That is her guess, and the person who settles it is Eli.
What is still open: whether Eli was flooded or just tired, and what he wants. Eli settles that, by answering when asked in Listening so they feel heard.
The repair. Maya notices her face is hot and says: "That came out harsher than I meant. Can we start over? I'd like to tell you what I'm asking for, not what I think you feel." Eli puts the phone down. Maya adds: "I'm sorry I said you never wash up. That wasn't fair; I just want the sink clear by 8." She has named what she did, said she is sorry, and offered a fix, and she has not asked for forgiveness. If it had kept rising, she could have said: "I'm flooded and need a break. Can we pick this up at 7:30?" Under these assumptions, this keeps the talk going. It does not tell us whether Eli will agree to her request; Making a clear request covers that.
- R is for Repair, from the Gottman Institute: the definition of a repair attempt and the categories of phrases. Chosen because it explains why agreeing on phrases in advance matters.
- The six elements of an effective apology, Ohio State University News: a plain summary of the study, including its scenario.
3. Practice Practice
Minimum: write two repair phrases on your Conversation plan and one sentence you would use to call a pause. Time: about 30 minutes. Materials: your plan, a pen or the sheet on screen, and a friend if you want to rehearse out loud.
- Collect your own phrases. Look at the table in Repair attempts and the Phrases page. Pick two that sound like you. Say them aloud once. If a phrase feels fake in your mouth, change a word until it does not.
- Write your pause sentence. Use the shape: "I'm flooded and need a break. Can we pick this up at ___?" Use the break planner to fill in the time.
- Rewrite one criticism. Think of the last time you said "you always" or "you never." Rewrite it as one event and one effect. Check the rewrite with the draft check.
- Draft an apology if you owe one. Use the four parts in Apologizing for your part. Write it on the plan sheet or in the exercises on Practice sheets.
Ask the other person, at a calm time, to choose two phrases of their own. Compare the lists. If you agree on a silly signal (a word, an object), write it down so you both remember it. This works best with a partner, family member or housemate you expect to keep talking to; it fits less well with a contractor or a landlord.
4. Your disagreement Your disagreement
5. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Do you have two repair phrases you would be willing to say and to hear?
- Does your pause sentence name yourself ("I'm flooded") and a time you will return?
- Does your apology say what you did, that you are sorry and what you will do, without "if" or "but"?
- Have you left out any request for forgiveness, or at least placed it last?
Worked example
In the fictional case, Maya's plan sheet now holds two repair phrases ("Let me try that again" and "Can we slow down?"), a pause sentence ("I'm flooded and need a break. Can we pick this up at 7:30?") and an apology: "I'm sorry I said you never wash up. I'll tell you what I'm asking for next time." It names what she did, the regret and a repair. It has no "but." That meets each criterion.
Common mistakes
- Saying "calm down" to the other person. It tells them how to feel and is not a repair.
- Calling a break without a return time, so the other person hears it as walking out.
- Spending the break replaying the argument. Watch for the "I'm right and they are wrong" thought.
- Apologizing with "I'm sorry you feel that way." It does not name anything you did.
What is still unresolved
This chapter does not settle who is right, and it does not tell you what to ask for. Making a clear request covers that, and Options and agreements covers what happens after. Whether the other person will accept a repair attempt is theirs to decide. If the conversation keeps heating up in the same place, Getting a third party covers other help.